August 28, 2012

Legally registered voters are frantically contacting the ACLU of Colorado after receiving a letter from Secretary of State Scott Gessler asking them to either affirm their citizenship and supply proof – or remove themselves from the voter rolls.

“These individuals became citizens before registering to vote,” said Denise Maes, Public Policy Director at the ACLU of Colorado. “Mr. Gessler has no business intimidating model law-abiding citizens living and working in Colorado with his letter that risks discouraging voters from exercising their right to vote.”

Gessler mailed between 3,000 and 4,000 voters letters challenging their voter eligibility earlier this month and has scheduled a public meeting for Wednesday, August 29, 2010 at 1:00 p.m. to determine next steps.

“Mr. Gessler has no authority to move forward with this nor to do anything about the individuals that do not respond,” Maes said. “No one is legally required to respond to Mr. Gessler’s fishing expedition.”

Gessler has not produced one verifiable case of voter fraud – but is clearly intimidating legally registered voters, as evidenced by the number of citizens who have contacted the ACLU of Colorado, including:

Veronica Figoli. Ms. Figoli came to the U.S. from Venezuela in 1999 as a student and has since built a successful career as a marketing and communications specialist. She did not register to vote until she became a citizen in November 2011. “I’ve done everything for this country. But this letter makes me feel that no matter what I do I’ll always be a second class citizen.”

Charmaine Rose. Ms. Rose is a government attorney in Colorado. Originally from Canada, Rose came to the U.S. in 2000 on a work visa as an engineer. Following the completion of her studies, she chose to practice law in the U.S. and became a citizen in March 2012. She registered to vote immediately following the ceremony. “I am outraged that taxpayer funds are being used in such a wasteful manner.”

Markus Mayer. Born in Germany, Mr. Mayer moved to the U.S. in 2000 and has been working in Colorado as an IT specialist since 2006. Secretary of State Scott Gessler himself encouraged the new citizens at Meyer’s naturalization ceremony in November 2011 to register to vote. Mayer took Gessler’s advice and registered to vote in December 2011 but recently found himself forced to affirm his citizenship after receiving a letter from Gessler. “I am frustrated and disgusted with the whole matter.”

Under pressure from the ACLU of Colorado, the Douglas County School District (“DCSD”) late Tuesday afternoon lifted its order prohibiting journalist and videographer Brian Malone from attending school board meetings. The order was lifted in response to an ACLU demand letter sent late Monday afternoon by ACLU cooperating counsel Steve Zansberg and Chris Beall, of the Levine Sullivan Koch & Schulz law firm. In the letter, ACLU lawyers demanded that DCSD immediately withdraw its directive—issued last week—that prohibited Mr. Malone from attending any future school board meetings. The ACLU also demanded that DCSD immediately withdraw its directive that required Mr. Malone, unlike any other member of the public or press, to receive pre-approval from DCSD before audio or video recording public meetings conducted on DCSD grounds. In less than twenty-four hours, DCSD complied with each of the ACLU’s demands.

“We are encouraged by the school district’s prompt action that avoids a lawsuit and restores Mr. Malone’s constitutional right to attend meetings of public bodies under the same terms as any other journalist or member of the public, said Mark Silverstein, ACLU Legal Director. “Access to public meetings for the general public and the media in particular is an essential part of a democracy.”

Silverstein noted that unfortunately, over the last several years, the inner workings of the Douglas County School Board have become less and less transparent. According to a study published by EdNews Colorado, since 2007, the Douglas County School Board has more than doubled its use of secretive “executive sessions” and dramatically limited the amount of time it spends in public session. “Given these developments,” Silverstein said, “access to school board meetings by journalists like Mr. Malone is particularly important.”

At the last school board meeting on August 7, DCSD ejected Mr. Malone after he placed his video camera tripod in a location that allowed the camera to capture the faces of the individuals making presentations to the board – the same location where he had been allowed to videotape during every meeting over the last three months. The meeting continued uninterrupted until a DCSD security official and the Castle Rock police demanded that Mr. Malone remove his camera. The officers eventually ushered Mr. Malone out of the building and then ordered him to appear in court in October to face a criminal charge of “disrupting a lawful assembly.” The ACLU of Colorado, through cooperating counsel Daniel Recht, of Recht and Kornfeld, will defend Malone in that criminal case.

While ejecting Mr. Malone, the DCSD security official informed the journalist that he was now prohibited from entering any school district property for any purpose. On Monday, Mr. Malone received a formal letter from DCSD confirming the prohibition was still in place, except that Mr. Malone may enter the schools his two daughters attend. DCSD added a restriction prohibiting Mr. Malone from using any recording device on any DCSD property without prior approval, a limitation not placed on the general public or other journalists.

The ACLU responded with a letter to DCSD’s legal counsel late Monday. The letter advised that Mr. Malone was a journalist who had a right to attend school board meetings and be treated the same as other journalists and members of the public. The letter also warned that if the ban order were not rescinded by close of business on Tuesday, ACLU lawyers would seek relief in court.

“DCSD’s limitations on Mr. Malone were clearly a violation of his constitutional rights,” said ACLU cooperating counsel Steve Zansberg. “We are gratified that Douglas County School District has agreed to restore Mr. Malone’s ability to do his journalistic work by covering school board meetings and those of other local public bodies on District grounds.”

more on this case

In a follow-up to the ACLU's letter of July 16, which criticized a "Gypsy scams" alert as encouraging racial profiling, the ACLU sent a follow-up letter congratulating the Arapahoe County Sheriff for his response, which included discontinuing training seminars sponsored by a consulting group that employed ethnic-based characterizations of criminal activity. 

more on this case